ARMA Quality Asphalt Roofing Case-study

QARC Case Studies

The QARC awards program seeks to recognize the top asphalt roofing projects in North America. Learn more about the winning projects and why asphalt roofing was chosen.

2014

Gold
Doral City Hall- Office Building
Address: 8401 NW 53rd Street
Company: Precision Roofing Corp

Government buildings are under tight scrutiny to not only protect assets, reduce cost and assure longevity, but also respond to the ever growing need for installing energy-efficient roof systems. Doral City Hall is the perfect example of how asphaltic roofing does it all. The system consisted of multiple roof areas, including lightweight insulating concrete that used a nailable venting base sheet, 3 plies of premium glass ply, and an energy-efficient cap sheet that exceeded the reflectance requirements of ENERGY STAR®, Title 24 and the Miami 21 Initiative. Another roofing area was built over structural concrete.

This system incorporated the use of GAF GAFGLAS® Stratavent® Eliminator™ venting base sheet directly over ISO insulation, which also helped reduce the overall cost of the project by eliminating the need for an overlay board and a mopping of asphalt because Precision Roofing Corp. could simultaneously attach the base and first interply. Because the architect specified a roof that would last, Precision believed in the durability and reliability of this redundant system. Using innovative asphaltic roofing products like the highly-reflective EnergyCap® BUR cap sheet, they were able to meet high

Doral City Hall- Office Building  - Julio Martinez<br /><br />
Doral City Hall- Office Building  - Julio Martinez<br /><br />
Silver
Publix #1382
Address: 6876 Collins Ave
Company: Advanced Roofing, Inc.

Publix Super Market, one of the top 10 largest supermarket chains in the U.S. with over 165,000 employees, trust their roofing specification to a composite built up/modified bitumen system. Advanced Roofing is one of Publix’s preferred roofers and have installed asphaltic roofing systems for the company since 1996.

Publix chose asphaltic roofing because they believe it’s the best system to keep their products dry and customers safe. They weren’t comfortable with a single ply of protection, instead they prefer the redundancy of asphalt. Store 1382 in Miami, included a metal deck, 2 layers of ISO installed in accordance with FM Global requirements, a GAFGLAS® Stratavent® Eliminator™ Perforated venting base sheet, 3 plies of FlexPly ® 6 and a GAF PRF SBS FR Modified bitumen cap sheet. It was finished with an ENERGY STAR® rated coating that not only made the roof look great but also helped reduce energy costs and fight global warming.

Advanced Roofing recommends the use of asphaltic roofing to any professional looking for a bulletproof roof. It not only provides multilayer protection, but has a 100+ year track record, waterproofing and adhesion characteristics.

Publix #1382 - Danny Stokes<br /><br />
Publix #1382 - Danny Stokes<br /><br />
Bronze
Everett Victorian - Historic Laurel
Address: 1110 Montgomery Street
Company: Certified Incorporated

Formerly known as Phelps Mansion, this historic Victorian was built in 1888 by Edward Phelps, who was the first mayor of Laurel, MD. During his 7 terms in office from 1895- 1902, he was responsible for bringing electric street lights, brick-paved roads, a telephone system and a railroad that connected Laurel to Washington, D.C. During renovation, Certainteed Highland Slate was chosen primarily because it imitated natural slate, which was a period material for this historic home, and it was significantly cheaper than any slate or synthetic roofing product. It was also one of the few products that the local historic commission would approve for this home in order meet their stringent guidelines. Unlike other slate options, this asphalt product was easy to work with and provided a safer working environment. As noted in the pictures, this asphalt roofing product works great on historic buildings that are trying to replicate an original look and feel. Ceritified Incorporated highly recommends using this asphalt roofing product to other contractors working on historic restoration projects.

Everett Victorian - Historic Laurel - Jim Lessig<br /><br />
Everett Victorian - Historic Laurel - Jim Lessig<br /><br />

2013

Gold
NOAA building in La Jolla
Address: 8901 La Jolla Shores Drive
Company: Protech Roofing Service

It may not sound like a massive project when considering building size alone, but when combining the other requirements — creating a roofing system that would assure redundancy and long-term performance, accommodating over 800 stand-up solar panels and meeting the stringent requirements dictated by CA Title 24 — the complexity of the build rose significantly. Working together as a team with their specifiers, the general contractor and GAF, the manufacturers for this project were able to master each and every hurdle. The system included EnergyGuard™ Tapered Iso, and over lay of EnergyGuard Perlite, GAFGLAS® Ultima 80™ base sheet , 2 plies of GAFGLAS FlexPly™ 6  and GAFGLAS EnergyCap™ BUR Mineral Surface Cap sheet. A base, two plies and a cap is a common spec in California, but nothing about this job was common. Complex and beautiful, yes, but common, no. BUR rose to the challenge, providing a reflective, redundant, compliant roofing system that meets the needs of today, and as an energy-efficient facility, the needs of years to come as well!

NOAA building in La Jolla - Protech Roofing Service<br /><br />
Silver
MCCA Residence
Address: Robert & Alma Vankregten
Company: Chris Howard Roofing, LLC

Robert Vankregten is a retired ship captain and engineer. He and his wife, Alma, live in an upscale neighborhood called "Evergreen" in Mill Creek, Washington. Evergreen and other surrounding communities are governed by the Mill Creek Community Association (MCCA). MCCA's roofing standards are some of the highest in the state and are often adopted by other upscale homeowners associations within the area. Their acceptable roofing products are tile, slate, metal, cedar shake, and a few heavyweight asphalt shingles. First and foremost, the homeowner wanted a roof that would last a long time, look good on their home, and require low maintenance. They also wanted it to look like their existing cedar shake roof and accent the color of the home and the extensive brickwork on the siding and chimneys. Living in the Northwest and in a development that has numerous trees and an abundant amount of rain, the homeowners also wanted a roof that wasn’t “noisy” when it rained nor easily susceptible to algae growth or color fading like some of their neighbors’ roofs. Having considered all factors, they chose the PABCO Paramount Advantage® Heavyweight Signature Cut Asphalt Shingle in the color Oakwood. The limited lifetime warranty, the 110-mph wind warranty, and the Scotchgard™ algae-resistant warranty made it easier for them to choose this roofing product. 

Once installed on this steep hip-roof, it closely duplicated the appearance of the old cedar shake roof. These heavyweight asphalt shingles will last three times as long as the cedar shakes and will require little to no maintenance.

The homeowners were absolutely thrilled with their completed roof! Since completing this project, the roofing contractor has installed several other roofs in the Evergreen community and in surrounding neighborhood's using the same products with different colors.

MCCA Residence - Chris Howard<br /><br />
Bronze
American Life & Accident Insurance Company
Address: 471 West Main Street
Company: American Roofing & Metal Co., Inc. (AR&M)

The environmentally-conscious owner initially specified a 2-ply modified bitumen system with a cool roof coating. Before tear-off started, however, the owner asked AR&M to research a vegetative roof option and very quickly the “cool” top coat was replaced with a “greenest of green” vegetative solution. The JM modified bitumen system still remained the very best solution under a vegetative system. It is watertight, durable and will hold up for years, according to AR&M’s project manager Troy Huffman. The stainless steel leak detection system laid over the DuraBoard® insulation allows any future water leaks to be pinpointed to the exact square inch. A possible “suck back” issue due to the building’s negative air pressure was resolved by using the JM urethane adhesive to adhere the DynaWeld™ base sheets at all perimeter walls, past the first joint in the DuraBoard® insulation, and at a minimum of three feet from the penetrations. The two plies of base and the cap sheet were then torched down with no adverse issues and AR&M’s ‘green team’ installed the multilayer vegetative roof system.

American Life & Accident Insurance Company - Sarah Tholen (by Judy Forbes / Tailwinds Marketing)<br /><br />
Honorable Mention
Brent Gibson Classic Home Design
Address: 415 W 15th St. Ste. 1
Company: J&L Construction & Remodeling, L.L.C
Honorable Mention
Saint Petersburg College
Address: 2465 Drew Street
Company: McEnany Roofing and Contracting, Inc.
Honorable Mention
Casa Del Sol Townhomes
Address: 5213 El Mercado Parkway
Company: Creative Roofing of Northern California

2012

Gold
Deerfield Residence
Address: 1700 Hickory Knoll Dr.
Company: Precise Construction

The asphalt roofing system on this residential project located in Deerfield, Illinois, embodies the qualities that the program strives to recognize each year: beautiful, affordable and reliable. With the installation of a new, designer, double-laminate shingle, it was the first of its kind to be used in the Chicago area. Installed on multiple roofing planes, attention to detail was paramount to the roof’s uniform appearance.  The homeowner desired the aesthetic appeal of a slate roof without the high cost and expensive installation of slate. This new shingle is a departure from the traditional architectural shingle that we see so much of today, giving the home the unique curb appeal that the owner desired and making it the envy of the neighborhood.

Deerfield Residence - Joe Krysiak<br /><br />
Deerfield Residence - Joe Krysiak<br /><br />
Deerfield Residence - Joe Krysiak<br /><br />
Silver
Seagoville Residence
Address: 1608 Bent Tree Rd.
Company: Legends Roofing

Flexibility was key for this project. With the house’s unique dome shape, asphalt shingles were required for this roof’s triangular sections and dramatic slope. Heavier roofing materials like metal and slate would have proved too cumbersome for this tornado-prone area.  Asphalt’s versatility is showcased on this house as the different sized roof planes are seemingly tailored with designer asphalt shingles in a classic burnt sienna color. Because of the dry, warm climate in Texas, the high fire-resistance rating of asphalt shingles made it the obvious choice over other roofing materials like wooden shake.  A combination of unique design and practicality makes this project a success story for asphalt shingles.

Seagoville Residence - Jacqi Ragsdale<br /><br />
Seagoville Residence - Jacqi Ragsdale<br /><br />
Seagoville Residence - Jacqi Ragsdale<br /><br />
Seagoville Residence - Jacqi Ragsdale<br /><br />
Bronze
Federal Reserve Bank of Atlanta - Miami Branch
Address: 9100 N.W. 36th Street
Company: Advanced Roofing, Inc

The most expansive project in this year’s program, this 257,000-square-foot roof is covered with an asphaltic modified bitumen system. Because of Florida’s climate, including an intense UV light and strong winds during hurricane season, an asphalt modified roof was the clear-cut choice for this building. Boasting 140-mph wind resistance and an ENERGY STAR® rating, the owner can rely on the roofing component to be durable and that the energy costs will be reduced over time. Affordability and ease of installation made asphalt the material of choice for this project.

Federal Reserve Bank of Atlanta - Miami Branch - Kevin Kornahrens<br /><br />
Federal Reserve Bank of Atlanta - Miami Branch - Kevin Kornahrens<br /><br />
Honorable Mention
18807 332nd. St.
Address: 18807 332nd. St.
Company: M & J Construction of Moorhead, Inc.
Honorable Mention
Comfort Suites
Address: Rieff St.
Company: Will Pro Roofing and Construction LLC
Honorable Mention
Boesch Residence
Address: 38 Round Terrace
Company: OnShore Roofing
Honorable Mention
Bryn Mawr Firehouse
Address: 901 W. Lancaster Avenue
Company: Jim Miller, Inc.

2011

Gold
Frank M Johnson Montgomery Courthouse
Address: One Church Street
Company: Advanced Roofing Inc.

Located in Montgomery, AL, this courthouse turned to asphalt to adhere to strict design criteria in a historical district. While not seen, asphalt underlayments play a key role in providing a watertight roofing system. Due to the tough access and difficult roofing, the modified roofing made it easier than installing a comparable single ply membrane. The self-adhering base sheet allowed an easier installation and the SRI on the cap sheet was as high and higher then some single plys. This asphalt system is aesthetically-pleasing, waterproof and includes the specifications to meet energy codes and historic codes without sacrificing quality.

Frank M Johnson Montgomery Courthouse - Ricky Gunvaldsen<br /><br />
Frank M Johnson Montgomery Courthouse - Ricky Gunvaldsen<br /><br />
Silver
Mosaic
Address: 300 North Akard Street
Company: Texas Roof Management Inc

This Dallas, TX, renovation project dealt with many challenges to complete the roofing system. From the removal of four layers of existing roofing, to being able to withstand standing water, to the 48 new roof drains, to the difficulty in staging and safety requirements during construction, the final product doesn’t fall short to the challenges that stood before it. The asphalt system went down easily and quickly, and the checkerboard design, with the Mosaic logo on the highest roof level, there will be a long-lasting impression on the Dallas skyline. As to the motivating design criteria, the Owner of the Mosaic wanted a memorable finished product ... which as mentioned previously, was definitely achieved!

Bronze
Struthers Residence
Address: 5316 Wynneford Way
Company: Baker Roofing Co.

The loan residential winner for the firs QARC program from Raleigh, NC, showcased asphalt shingles and how they can make a roof the main attraction. With longevity, the ease of installation and the multiple planes covered on the roof, it was a “no-brainer” to turn to asphalt for this project, and it’s a good example why four out of five homes are covered by asphalt shingles in the U.S. This case study allowed Baker Roofing Co. a chance to highlight how asphalt can drastically transform a home’s appearance, and make it the envy of the neighborhood.

Struthers Residence - Brendan Hale<br /><br />
Struthers Residence - Brendan Hale<br /><br />
Struthers Residence - Brendan Hale<br /><br />
Honorable Mention
Levine Children's Hospital
Address: 1000 Blythe Blvd
Company: CRS Of Monroe, Inc.
Honorable Mention
LSU School of Veterinary Medicine
Address: 1909 Skip Bertman Dr.
Company: Roof Technologies, Inc
Honorable Mention
Miami-Dade County GSA Trade Shop Facility
Address: 3501 NW 46 Street
Company: Unlimited Roofing Services, Inc.
Honorable Mention
Marston & Moffat Water Treatment Plants
Address: 6100 W. Quincy Ave.
Company: D & D Roofing, Inc.